Film of the Year # 9 - A Star is Born

A Star is Born (Bradley Cooper)

I went into this with zero familiarity, somehow, for the story, despite this being the fourth iteration of a classic Hollywood tragedy. I'd seen and loved the trailer, but I didn't know what to expect. It's a testament to the strength of this year in movies that this actually wasn't the most emotional experience I had in theaters all year, because I cried buckets watching this, the kind of crying where you have to make sure when you leave that everyone else has tear tracks and red noses when you all exit together so you don't have to feel ashamed of yourself for letting so loose. This is a gorgeous melodrama that gives into the fantasy with full sincerity. It sweeps you up and disarms you. It feels refreshingly timeless - there are only a few details that place it clearly in the moment, which takes the focus off the ins and outs of show biz and into the hearts of its characters.

Those characters are played with full conviction and palpable chemistry by Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga. It just wouldn't work without them giving their all here, absolutely nailing it in the musical sequences and giving total credibility to the big dramatic beats. The on stage performances feel remarkably genuine, no doubt bolstered by the real crowds that were present. It's a shame that the film does drop off in quality for awhile as the live performances give way to rehearsals and recording sessions as Gaga's Ally blossoms into pop stardom. But the first act is strong enough to carry through a few stumbling blocks, and the passion and immediacy of the beginning of the relationship makes its breakdown all the more wrenching. This is a stunning achievement for a first-time director and an actress making her film debut. They shine onscreen, and we can't help but watch until our eyes water.